Posted on

2018 Year in Review: You Can’t Put a Bow On It (Or Maybe You Can)

And now its that time of year we do the annual Mostly Medicaid (really Clay’s) Year in Review. For past reviews, visit here and here. If this is your first Year in Review with us, fair warning: it’s the one time I get all sappy. Provides a nice contrast to the cynicism and sarcasm you probably read the RoundUp for.[1]

 

You will need tissues.

 

Winter is a time for thinking.

A certain type of thinking, really. Reflection, introspection. All the eckshuns.

Spring is for hope and eagerness. Summer is for playing (and if you are a teenager in love it is a time of rhapsody and skirting curfews). Fall is for slowing down a bit, and breathing in the fresher, cooler air. Watching the oranges and reds and yellows on the trees.

But winter is a time for thinking.

And so I think, sitting in front of my fireplace. Warming my toes, my thoughts and-  I hope – my heart. For just as winter brings cold outside, it also brings cold to many hearts.

Hot soup can help. Or a game of cards with an old friend.

 

***

 

Sometimes we do things not knowing exactly why, but trusting they are important and will be valuable at some point in the future.

About 20 years ago, I started saving every single card people gave me and put them in a box. After a year or so, I outgrew that box. And now I am about to outgrow a large plastic tub.

Being a strict minimalist, cards are the one thing I let myself pack-rat.

I can remember the exact conversation that started this habit. A friend of mine and I both loved the same band (the Weakerthans). In their song Left and Leaving[2], are the lyrics:

 

Duct-tape and soldered wires
New words for old desires
And every birthday card I threw away

I wait in 4/4 time
Count yellow highway lines
That you’re relying on to lead you home

 

When discussing this song, my friend was struck by this particular line about throwing away birthday cards. They said something to this effect: “You know, every time someone sends you a card, they were thinking of you. Thinking of you enough to spend $2.99[3], write something about you specifically from their heart, and place it in the mail or hand it to you. We really shouldn’t throw those cards away.”

And from that moment on I didn’t.

I get rid of most things. I hate clutter. I don’t hold onto anything else for sentimental reasons. But – I have a box of birthday cards, get well cards, letters, graduation notes, thank you notes,[4] and myriad other similar items that has grown over the past 2 decades.

My thought is that one day when I am 80, I will sit and read these cards and be reminded of a time that I was loved and surrounded by those that I loved. That memories will flood in and drown out the sadness I see so often in the nursing homes I visit. That the effort to read someone’s poor handwriting inside a Snoopy-themed missive will pay off in smiles and remembered inside jokes.

Hold that thought. This will be the bow we put on the boxes that are sometimes painful to open.

 

 

But first, let’s talk about what happened in 2018 in Medicaid

 

Its been a wild, wild Medicaid ride hasn’t it dear reader? I looked back at the topics in our Monthly Medicaid News Roundtables, and made a short list of major happenings in our world this year:

 

Work requirements; Good vs Evil; Darth Vader; Orange Man Bad

It’s all a bit overblown, don’t you think? Reasonable people can disagree without casting each other as Nazi’s. At least they used to be able to. I yearn for a return of reasonable people discussing Medicaid. Hint – it does need fixing. Start there.

Another hint- a rebalancing of the state/federal “partnership” is long overdue.

 

Expansion on the ballot

This one took me by surprise. I wasn’t surprised that in state after state people voted for it (put any entitlement on the ballot and of course people will vote for it). I was surprised that it can even work this way. And I’m still not sure it can because it all has to go through the budget process. Stay tuned…

 

Social determinants

All 3 of these things are true:

  1. I believe food, clothing and shelter do impact healthcare outcomes
  2. I can’t sit through another academic presentation on this
  3. Its time to share info on specific, practical, starting point strategies. Go!

 

Managed care in the Tarheel State

North Carolina was added to the “managed care” column this year. Seems like 85% of the 2018 Medicaid conversations I had were around this. Now if we can get through the protests (I know we don’t have them yet, but I will bet you anything we will).

 

 

 

And now back to the things you think about sitting next to a fireplace (a wood fireplace, the only real kind)

 

Yes, it gets cold even in Birmingham, Alabama. Not as cold as some of the places you lunatic Yankees live (I’m looking at you my good friends in Michigan, Ohio, Maine- I mean, why not just live at the North Pole? That’s the one with penguins, right? Or is it the south pole? Or both?).

And I love fire.

I was the kid who other kids could not play with because I taught them how to play with fire. My first “date” was when I was seven and I went to see E.T. in theatres with a little girl my age. When her parents dropped her off, the first thing I did (to try and impress her?) was walk over to the nearest tree and show her how to strike a match and throw it at the tree.

I like fire. And fireplaces.

Many of you who have spoken to me the past few years know I have been slowly remodeling a 1974 elevated ranch. Well, I finally got around to fixing the fireplace. Which really was a chimney repair/ash dump investigation/damper replacement/flue cleaning/new cap install project. Just a small project. Only took me 2 months.

But now its done. And we sit by the fire whenever we can (I have come to think that first-thing-in-the-morning fires are the best. How nice it is to start your day with a fire and its heat and its light and the smoke wisping up into the flue as you drink a cup of coffee. Or see you children stumble out into the living room in their pajamas).

And these are the things I think about when I sit next to my newly working fireplace and stare into the flames.

I do not think about Medicaid.

I think about people.

 

My mom brought me a stack of old cards and I finally cried about Daddy dying for the first time almost a year after he died

 

As many of you know, Daddy died a year ago today (12/28/2018). My grieving has been different than most of my family members. For whatever reason, I did not really cry a lot when it happened. Or at the funeral. Or pretty much the entire year of 2018. I did cry here and there, but only a little.

I wasn’t holding it back (at least I don’t think I was). But it was noticeable to others, including my daughter who asked me – “Are you not sad? Now that Papa is gone?” I didn’t have a good answer. And I still don’t.

I am sad. But also not. Daddy left me with a clear view of death.

And its not that I don’t think about. I think about him most days. But in a good way. Memories of his little strange habits, or of conversations we had. Or ones I wish we would have had.

I try to spend my rememberings on things from when he was most alive. I do try to block out the gruesome final months of his life as he succumbed to brain cancer.

That was hard.

So hard that all I could do was work. Sitting in the room next to his, working away. Furiously trying to deny that he was 10 feet from me, his body and mind mangled more each day by this evil opponent.

I have many, many, many regrets in my life. But the one that has stuck with me most this past year is that instead of spending most of my time next to his bedside holding his hand in those last few weeks, I instead spent most of my time typing and analyzing and staring at a computer just a room away.

I’m sorry about that, Daddy.

 

 

I have learned in recent years, sometimes all our urges to find a silver lining, to make a happy ending, to put a bow on it (just look at all the idioms we have for this)- sometimes we can’t overcome the brutality of certain events. Sure, we can say “they’ll always live in our hearts” (never has made sense to me), or “make the most of life since its so short, and it will be ok as long as you live a full life” (always seemed like it missed the main point).

Sometimes we have to face the reality of loss. We have to accept for what it is. We can’t deny it. We can’t escape forever into our hobbies or pursuits or careers. Loss (primarily death) refuses to actually be transformed into something less than an awful, horrible, total thing.

We can’t put a bow on it.

 

 

I can still remember calling a friend and colleague who shares this Medicaid world of ours last February. I was at the Medicaid Innovations conference in Florida, and had stepped out to make a call to Dr. G.

The purpose of my call was to ask his opinion on a partner I was considering bringing on. Dr. G is someone whose opinion I trust (and his judgment even more). He started out as a client years and years ago.

And he is the reason I have a beard.

Dr. G was a key client stakeholder for a giant technology implementation contract my company at the time had (if I remember correctly, about $80M over a few years). In my first meeting with Dr. G, at the end of the meeting he had a new agenda item. It went something like this:

“You seem like a very impressive young man. And it seems like you have everything in order for the preparation for this project.”

He paused.

“But you look so young. I for one would appreciate a little more gray hair on a project of this size and complexity.”

I have always had a baby face.

I thought for a moment.

“Give me a month, Dr. G.”

 

I spent the next month growing a beard to try and look older (it used to work for my friends in high school when they tried to buy cigarettes, so why not for this?)

At our next meeting, I pointed to the beard.

“Do you feel better now, Dr. G?” I asked.

“Yes.”

It was the start of a wonderful working relationship, and I have gotten to know one of the most committed, honorable men in this space. All because I threw away my razor.

 

 

Back to the call from sunny Florida this past February.

After giving me his insights into the question that occasioned the call, he also asked how I was doing.

And I told him it was hard to have not cried about Daddy yet now (at that time) that it had been more than a month.

And he told me of the story about how it took him a long time to cry about the loss of his parents. He shared a sacred part of his life with me that day.

And he let me know it was ok to not cry yet. But that it would come.

And to hope that God would bless me for it to come in a private moment. For when it comes, there will be no holding back the tears. It will overwhelm you and consume you and take control of not just tear ducts, but also breathing and your muscles and all your emotions and your mind. It will be an experience of recognizing the totality of the loss.

And then it will somehow be better.

 

 

My mom has been cleaning out things since Daddy died. I think people do this for various reasons. Some people do it to get rid of clutter. Some people do it to busy themselves and avoid thinking about the one who has died.

Some people do it as a way to remember the people who have died.

I think that’s what Momma has been doing with all her cleaning.

And in cleaning out things, she found a stack of letters and cards of mine. She brought them over one day in early November and left them on my kitchen counter.

At first all I noticed was the letter from my elementary school congratulating me on coming in 2nd place in the city-wide spelling bee. And I remembered how much I did not like the experience of 2nd place. And I remember vividly the face of the little girl who beat me (I do not remember the word I lost on).

And I told my children the story of this. And they laughed. And that was that.[5]

The next day, I saw the stack of cards on the counter again. If your house is like mine, there is a constant battle between you and one spot on your counter to keep it free from mail or books or keys or change or Home Depot receipts. The stack of cards was in that spot, staring back at me.

That’s when I noticed the other things under the spelling bee letter.

I opened the first one and began to sob. It was a highschool graduation card to me from Daddy’s very best friend. Emmet Ladner. Emmet and Daddy became fast friends on the Mississippi Gulf Coast due to their shared love of fishing. Emmet had died 10 years or more ago and I watched Daddy miss him.

And then I opened more cards. Many of them from Daddy. Or from aunts long dead. Or friends forgotten.

And I simply could not stop crying. But it was of joy. I was remembering the good things, all the many people God had placed in our lives and the times they thought enough of me to spend a few bucks and write down a few thoughts about me that they felt in their hearts.

It was not – as Dr. G had wished for me – a private moment.

My wife was there to hug me. My kids were there to see my cry. And I’m glad they did.

 

 

 

3 Kinds of People

I think this year I realized recently that there are mostly 3 kinds of people:

  1. Those you don’t want to be around. You choose to avoid these.
  2. Those you do want to be around, but can’t. They may be far away, they may dead, they may have an illness that prevents contact. They may be missionaries in a country where they have to be almost like secret spies for Jesus or else get killed, and that’s the reason you probably won’t ever get to see them again. There may be an un-crossable emotional rift between the two of you, spreading across and between your hearts like a chasm. With only darkness and echoes where what once was joy and laughter. And a bond you never doubted until one day it simply wasn’t there.

There are many reasons that created situation #2- the people you want to be around but cannot.

And that leaves us with the 3rd kind:

  1. People you do want to be around and still can.

 

I now think about the people in #2 a lot. And you should, too. You shouldn’t avoid it (if you do).

Its good to think about the people in #2. It is important to miss them. Important to grieve. To mourn. To ache. To cry.

 

But I need to start paying more attention to the people in group #3. (And so do you).

 

And this is where we put the bow on all this.

 

 

 

Card by card

I’m still saving this big ole’ box for when I am old and gray. I’m working on the old part. And the gray pokes through. But hopefully I still have decades longer to fill this box up and look at it when I am old.

But – I did sneak a peak at a few of them when Momma brought them over. A little stack. A small bundle of memories that jarred in me tears of joy.

And I would like to share just a few of those cards – or rather share a bit about who sent them- with you before we land this plane.

  • Emmet and Nell-  They are both dead and gone, but some of my earliest memories are of them.
  • Jo Elaine –Jo is my aunt and she’s a peach. On my Nanny’s side (who has been gone a long time). Jo is one of many aunts who always thinks of me on birthdays even though I rarely see her.
  • Bobby and Betty –Mr. B was also one of Daddy’s very best friends. I remember riding my bike next to he and Daddy as they ran at 4am each morning in Gulfport, MS. Mr. B was a Marine, rough around the edges but with a gooey center that loved people. He was a good man. He is also now gone.
  • Carrol and Nancy –Carrol was a true friend to Daddy in his toughest times, hiring him to work in his hardware store during one of Daddy’s hardest bouts of depression (it lasted 3 years that time). Nancy died in a car crash in the rain on an interstate exit ramp. But she was a dear friend to my mom before she left. Momma still misses her and I think of her every time I pass that exit ramp.
  • John and Louise – a sweet, sweet couple who managed a large farm operation in Kiln, MS (where I watched Brett Favre play highschool ball). They stopped smoking when 7 year old me told them I couldn’t be around it. They are both gone now but in no way forgotten.
  • Ganky and Pappy- Pappy was a retired railroad man and he sure did love Ganky. She was the first person I ever heard of with Lou Gehrig’s disease. Pappy once snuck into Daddy’s garden in the middle of the night to dig up and replace small tomato plants with very large ones to convince Daddy of the astounding overnight effectiveness of Miracle Grow. They have both been gone a long time.
  • Aunt Annette – one of my mom’s aunts who still sent me cards even though she had been estranged for decades. My mom misses her a lot.

And so many more even just in this little stack. From my siblings, from Momma and Daddy. Somewhere in the big box is a letter from my friend Cecille who died (along with her little brother) when she was hit by a train in her late teens. Way too many to write about.

What do I take away from all these cards? People come and go and everyone dies. But in the in-between parts, the times you spend with them, the times they still send you cards (and even after that when you read the cards years later)- something amazing happens. Somehow, despite all the insurmountable despair of loss we all must face, somehow we have the capacity to love one another.

Let’s do more of that in 2019.

 

One last detour

I almost didn’t write this part up. This thing has gotten way, way longer than I intended. And I hope for the 2019 Year in Review I can find a topic besides death and loss. 3 years in a row is surely enough.

But this part is fun.

When I was kid, we went to every Auburn game. Home and away.

This was before that jackass Alabama fan poisoned the big oaks on Toomer’s corner.

Back when you could still park all over campus on gameday, in crazy places. And camp out for 3 days before the game with 100,000 of your closest friends.

Like an idiot, I hated much of those times as a kid. Or at least I thought I did.

Now, I do things like return to Auburn and walk around with my kids. Just like Daddy did with me.

Not knowing why, we often return to the places our fathers took us.

What was really crazy, was that Daddy would just walk on the field after a game and walk into the locker rooms just to talk with players. And after that we would walk over to the players dorms and hang out with them. So as a 12 year old I’m chilling with the dude that just kicked the winning goal against LSU. Or the guy that missed the pass that could have beat Arkansas in the last 3 seconds. Those 2 guys have very different moods, by the way.

But the point is that Daddy had a way of getting into places (and people’s hearts) simply by acting like he was supposed to be there. Let them tell you no if they feel they must. But until then, sneak into the stadium.

And that’s what we did a few weeks ago. Passing through Auburn on our way back home from a trip with the kiddos.

There was one gate open at Jordan-Hare stadium that day (pronounced Jur-dan for those of you who don’t know). I snuck in first and waved to the kids to follow.

There was a worker there. He looked at me.

I froze.

“I gotta lock the gate, so please make it quick.”

I had the feeling he sees this a lot. And he was so kind and probably is to every Auburn fool wandering back in. Whoever he is, he was my hero that day. And I hope I get chances to be so kind to others in need of sneaking into stadiums, too.

We go back to the places our fathers took us.

 

Wrapping Up (Finally!)

So I know what I need to do now. How 2019 needs to go.

My box is overflowing.

I need to send more birthday cards so others can put them in a big box and pull them out one day and go through each one and defiantly shake their fist in the face of death and loss and separation and tell the Evil One he has not won because there was joy. There was love. There still is. But – most importantly- there still will be.

And it can be forever for those of us who choose it. Beyond time, forever joy. With our loved ones and with Christ. For all of you readers who are non-believers (so many of you are, and I hope you know by now I love you regardless of any differences of opinions or beliefs), suffer me one more time in 2018 to share the simple gospel:

You (and me and everyone ever born) are a sinner. You need a savior. His name is Jesus.

 

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year my dear readers! You are loved by me, each and every one of you. If you like you can print this out and put it in your box and count it as a card from me to you. Me thinking about you and writing it down.

Please don’t stop writing in (cl**@************id.com) and calling (919-727-9231). You have no idea how much it means to me when you write in and tell me your thoughts about what I write.

War Eagle!

Onward and Upward!

Trystero: The Father Sent the Son to Save the World (English)

 

 

 


[1] I have found my old love of footnotes again. It’s like a little side conversation beyond me and you. Titles that were also considered:

A Box of Letters

Looking At Life With Clear Eyes and A Full Heart

Memories as a Gift to Get Us Through Our Journey

Returning to the Places Our Fathers Took Us

 

[2] For those of you who have enjoyed my musical recommendations in the Roundup over the years, this song, album and band are in my opinion one of the most important things to happen to music in my lifetime. For people who have never heard The Weakerthans, I tell them their art is the closest thing to perfection in the combined genres of music and poetry that I have ever encountered. It may not be your style – but I drove from Baltimore to Toronto once just to see them play and its still one of the best life decisions I have made.

[3] For a fun look at the greeting card industry (including average prices, which have gone way up since the mid-1990s), see https://www.thesprucecrafts.com/greeting-card-industry-facts-and-figures-2905385

 

[4] Oxford forever! Grammarians, unite and #Resist! https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/explore/what-is-the-oxford-comma/

[5] 6 sentences in that segment started with “and.”

Posted on

Monday Morning Medicaid Must Reads: Dec 10th, 2018

Helping you consider differing viewpoints. Before it’s illegal.

In this issue…

Article 1:  Medicaid Access & Coverage to Care in 2017 (MHPA’s Institute for Medicaid Innovation, Oct 2018)

Clay’s summary:  The industry survey from this leading Medicaid health plan association doesn’t disappoint.
Key Excerpts from the Article:  … Key findings from the data were noted in the high-risk care coordination, value-based payment models, women’s health, and behavioral health sections. For instance, results from the survey demonstrate that the majority of Medicaid MCOs in 2017 performed a number of core functions in providing comprehensive, high-risk care coordination. The most commonly performed core functions included developing a plan of care for members, supporting adherence to the plan of care, engaging a care team of professionals to address the needs of the member, and conducting risk assessments….The findings also indicate that Medicaid MCOs are increasingly using value-based payment (VBP) models when providing care for their members. In 2017, half of Medicaid MCOs indicated that they were piloting population-specific VBP models, while over 15 percent were expanding successful pilots. Finally, approximately 10 percent of MCOs surveyed reported that they had extensive VBP arrangements in place in 2017. As barriers to VBP adoption are removed, we anticipate an increase in the number of Medicaid MCOs transitioning from the pilot phase to fully implemented arrangements….
 
 
Read full article in packet or at links provided

Article 2:  Who can be believed in medical research? Charles Barta, Nov 21 2018

Clay’s summary:  An AZ physician provides an overview of bogus medical and health systems theories throughout the years. Including that old chestnut about how expanding Medicaid would reduce ER in Oregon (that one’s a real knee-slapper!)
Key Excerpts from the Article:  … One interesting fact that has not been reported involves the idea that increasing Medicaid would clearly lower inappropriate emergency room visits and the expense these visits cost the public. We would save money…Oregon decided to prove this in 2009. It vastly increased the number of residents eligible for Medicaid. Unfortunately, the state didn’t have the funds to pay for this, so they put a lottery in place. Half the people eligible were given Medicaid while the other half became a “control group.” This was a scientifically perfect, randomized experiment. …The results? Two years later, the covered group had a 40 percent increase in unnecessary ER use. When a social experiment doesn’t work, the usual excuse of “we didn’t fund it enough — we need more money” wasn’t applicable. The next excuse, “The newly enrolled didn’t have time to get used to the system so they didn’t attempt to make (free) appointments with their doctors.” Two years later, a follow-up study was done. Surprise! The increase in unnecessary ER rose dramatically. The only news organization that reported this was NPR….
 
Read full article in packet or at links provided

Article 3:  Our opinion: State budget reforms are needed, Houma Today Editorial Board, Nov 19, 2018

Clay’s summary:  A small town newspaper comes out in favor of income verification and work requirements for Medicaid eligibility. They must be evil, GOP-loving, Trump worshiping [Insert current set of slurs media tells you to append to people with opinions non-leftist).
Key Excerpts from the Article:  … But some of these reforms make a lot of sense. For instance, income verification for Medicaid can limit paying out benefits to those who don’t qualify while making sure those who do qualify get the help they need….A recent state audit claimed that as much as $85 million could have been spent over the past several years on people who didn’t qualify for Medicaid. That’s because Health Department officials check income only once, at the time of the enrollee’s initial application for the program. They don’t check again until 12 months later, when the person applies for renewal of coverage. In the meantime, the person could have gotten a new job or increased income, becoming ineligible for Medicaid….
 
Read full article in packet or at links provided
Posted on

Menges Group 5 Slides Series for November 2018

The Menges Group puts out these great analyses and insights each month. And is kind enough to let us repost them for the MM audience. Check out themengesgroup.com to learn more about the work they do. 

Our November Edition of the 5 Slide Series focuses on the 2018 election results and conveys some of the potential implications of these results regarding Medicaid expansion.

Mid-Term Election Results and Medicaid Expansion Dynamics — November 2018

Posted on

Monday Morning Medicaid Must Reads: Nov 19th, 2018

Helping you consider differing viewpoints. Before it’s illegal.

In this issue…

Article 1: COUNTERPOINT: Medicaid expansion is unfunded, unsustainable for state of Nebraska

Clay’s summary: Voters didn’t listen to this dude.
Key Excerpts from the Article:  …It is also likely that expansion costs will far exceed projections, just as costs have in nearly every state that has expanded. Iowa spent over $150 million more than expected. Kentucky’s Medicaid program is facing a $296 million budget shortfall due to unpredictable costs (yes, the program itself is that much in debt). Ohio’s Medicaid program costs the state an average of $437 million a month…
Read full article in packet or at links provided

Article 2: Maryland might not have properly vetted some Medicaid enrollees

Clay’s summary: Perhaps there was maybe some payments that could have been somewhat non-compliant with the law but who’s to say, really? It’s a gray area- move along.
Key Excerpts from the Article: Maryland may have allowed residents who did not qualify for Medicaid into the government health program for the poor by failing to consider all of their income, according to a routine audit of the quasi-governmental agency that oversees the Maryland health exchange.
Read full article in packet or at links provided

Article 3: Virginia facing high unexpected Medicaid costs

Clay’s summary: Well at least they decided to expand and spend even more (this is all costs not-related to recent expansion largess).
Key Excerpts from the Article:
State officials said Friday that Virginia has about $460 million in unforeseen Medicaid costs. …The new costs, first reported by the Richmond Times-Dispatch, are unrelated to Virginia’s recent decision to expand Medicaid eligibility to low-income adults under the Affordable Care Act. …Instead, Secretary of Finance Aubrey Layne said much of the new costs stem from faulty forecasts overestimating the benefits of having private health insurers cover a greater number of some of the state’s more costly Medicaid recipients. Another reason for the increase is a higher-than-expected enrollment of children in the state’s Medicaid program, he said…
Read full article in packet or at links provided

Posted on

Monday Morning Medicaid Must Reads: Nov 12th, 2018

Helping you consider differing viewpoints. Before it’s illegal.

 
In this issue…
Article 1:

MACPAC urges Azar to pause, re-evaluate Arkansas’ Medicaid work requirements, Eli Richman, FierceHealthcare, Nov 9, 2018

Clay’s summary:
MACPAC feels left out with all the attention on work requirements, needed to go on record as raising yellow flag.
Key Excerpts from the Article:
In a letter to Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Alex Azar, the independent commission that advises CMS on policy matters said it was “highly concerned” about the statistics and recommended the state pause the program until adjustments can be made… The disenrolled individuals in Arkansas were unable to report work and community engagement activities as required by the policy, but the commission argued that the state’s approach contributed to the challenges. However, MACPAC cited extremely low rates of successful reporting: A whopping 91.6% of the beneficiaries required to report compliance failed to do so in September 2018…. “The low level of reporting is a strong warning signal that the current process may not be structured in a way that provides individuals an opportunity to succeed, with high stakes for beneficiaries who fail,”
Read full article in packet or at links provided
 

Article 2:

Medicaid Expansion Opponent Picked to Lead Medicaid, Steven Porter, Health Leaders Media, Oct 16, 2018

 
Clay’s summary:
The current CMS/Trump administration has repeatedly expressed a clear belief that CMS can leverage Medicaid to alleviate poverty vis a vis work requirements being asked for by states. Lefties keep repeating the same rebuttals (and effectively calling Ms. Verma a liar when she refutes leftist claims that work requirements’ main goal is to reduce Medicaid rolls), and have not offered any other solutions to alleviate poverty. In the lefty mind, CMS really only pays for things and does not have any other function. In a shocking turn of events, the current CMS/Trump administration (duly elected by American voters, despite what tin-foil hat wearing loony left zombies think re RussiaHoax) has appointed someone who has a history of not floating the pay-for-everything Medicaid mainstream. If your head did not explode from this paragraph- quick, go knit another protest hat to deal with the trauma of someone disagreeing with you!
Key Excerpts from the Article:
Mary Mayhew’s rise-out-of-poverty rhetoric around Medicaid policymaking aligns with statements made by Trump administration officials. Mayhew oversaw a shrinking state Medicaid program and opposed Medicaid expansion… One critic, a Democrat, described her as “antagonistic toward Medicaid.” …A former hospital lobbyist who spent most of the past decade as Maine’s health commissioner under Gov. Paul LePage has been tapped to lead Medicaid on the federal level. …Mary Mayhew earned a reputation in Maine as someone who, alongside LePage, championed additional limits on the public benefit programs she oversaw, reducing enrollment in the state’s Medicaid program by 67,000 beneficiaries between 2011 and 2015 then opposing Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act….
Read full article in packet or at links provided

Article 3:

Wisconsin Wins Federal Approval for Medicaid Work Requirements, Steven Porter, Health Leaders Media, Oct 31, 2018

Clay’s summary:
But, but, but- muh lawsuit!!!
Key Excerpts from the Article:
 
The state is the fifth to secure approval for such a program, but a federal judge blocked Kentucky’s waiver last summer, so Wisconsin is the fourth with an active waiver.
The federal government formally approved Wisconsin’s plan Wednesday to impose work requirements on certain Medicaid recipients, signaling that the Trump administration is not backing down from the controversial policy position.
Read full article in packet or at links provided
Posted on

Menges Group 5 Slides Series for August, September, & October 2018

The Menges Group puts out these great analyses and insights each month. And is kind enough to let us repost them for the MM audience. Check out themengesgroup.com to learn more about the work they do. 

The August edition quantifies Medicaid DSH payments, showing the progression of DSH spending in each state from 2013-2017.  The key takeaway is that Medicaid DSH has not dropped at all across the expansion states since 2013, even though this was intended to occur as one of the mechanisms to help offset the Federal costs of Medicaid expansion.

The September edition presents Medicaid data from our Pharmacy Practice, quantifying the differences in cost per prescription between the MCO and FFS settings in two selected high-volume therapeutic classes.  In both drug classes (as occurs with Medicaid prescriptions overall), the MCO setting is achieving large percentage savings relative to FFS.  However, the path taken to achieve these savings is quite different between the two drug classes shown.

October’s edition conveys some of our tabulations working with the recently published NCQA Medicaid health plan quality ratings for Rating Year 2018-2019.  AmeriHealth Caritas and UnitedHealthcare are the two top-rated national chain organizations in terms of their average NCQA rating across the states they serve.  Among the 13 Medicaid MCOs with a rating of 4.5 or above, the plans achieving this excellent quality score on the largest Medicaid membership base are Health Partners Plans in Pennsylvania, Neighborhood Health Plan of Rhode Island, and Priority Health in Michigan.

Medicaid DSH Spending Trends — August 2018

Medicaid MCO Rx Cost Savings at Therapeutic Class Level — September 2018

Medicaid MCO Quality Overview, NCQA Ratings for 2018-2019 — October 2018

Posted on

Monday Morning Medicaid Must Reads: October 29th, 2018

Helping you consider differing viewpoints. Before it’s illegal. 

 

Article 1:  

Report Asks About Quality Assurance in Medicaid Managed Care for Children, AJMC, Allison Inserro, 2/27/2018

Clay’s summary: Studies like this are strong support for the national Medicaid Quality Rating System (still to be implemented under the Mega Reg as of the time of writing)

Key Passage from the Article

A new report questions what metrics policy makers are using to evaluate whether or not children enrolled in Medicaid managed care organizations (MCOs) are receiving quality care, given the public investment these programs receive.

The report, from the nonpartisan Georgetown University Center for Children and Families (CCF), said that state Medicaid agencies and CMS do not use 1 common measurement for measuring quality of care.

Data and transparency about the quality of care for children are scant, the report said. There is no publicly accessible national database with information on how well individual MCOs are serving enrolled children.

For instance, there is no national database regarding the performance of individual MCOs with respect to Early and Periodic Screening, Diagnostic, and Treatment (EPSDT) services, which are a guaranteed benefit providing care to children with special needs.

  …

Read it here 


Article 2:   

How HEDIS, CMS Star Ratings, CQMs Impact Healthcare Payers, HealthPayer Intelligence, Thomas Beaton, 12/21/2017

Clay’s summary: Good overview for those just beginning to learn about quality rating systems in the space.

Key Passage from the Article

Quality performance metrics such as HEDIS, CMS Star Ratings, and standardized core quality measures (CQMs) can give consumers an objective indication of healthcare payer quality.

Standardized quality measures aggregate how well a payer has performed based on the regularity of services performed, improvements in patient health, and consumer satisfaction.  

Commercial, Medicaid, and Medicare payers can leverage quality metrics in order to position and market their health plans as ideal insurance options for beneficiaries.

HEDIS, CMS ratings, and CQMs measure similar healthcare services and consumer-facing operations, but some quality datasets are more specialized, including metrics such as consumer satisfaction rates or chronic disease screening activities.

  …

Read it here 

 

 


 

Article 3:   

CMS Scorecard for Medicaid, CHIP Measures Draws Scrutiny From State Directors, AJMC, Allison Inserro

Clay’s summary: So what’s your alternative? That the available data doesn’t support a meaningful dashboard is sort of the point, class…

Key Passage from the Article

CMS Monday released a scorecard that reports quality metrics voluntarily reported by states for Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP), as well as federally reported measures, but the association that represents state Medicaid directors expressed some concerns with the scorecard’s data and what sorts of conclusions may be drawn from them, given the huge variability of state programs, essentially giving it a score of “needs improvement.”

CMS said that it is the “first time” it is publishing state and federal administrative performance metrics; the first 3 areas to be included are state health system performance, state administrative accountability, and federal administrative accountability. Health metrics include things like well-child visits, mental health conditions, children’s preventive dental services, and other chronic health conditions.

  …

Read it here 

 


 

Posted on

Monday Morning Medicaid Must Reads: October 22nd, 2018

Helping you consider differing viewpoints. Before it’s illegal. 

 

Article 1:  

AHCA Points to Gains in Quality as House Panel Weighs SNF Oversight, Patrick Connole, Provider Magazine, 9/5/2018

Clay’s summary: Big Nursing Home lobby cries Uncle; asks for less regulation, please.

Key Passage from the Article

Ahead of a congressional hearing to scrutinize federal oversight of skilled nursing care, the American Health Care Association (AHCA) on Sept. 5 urged lawmakers to recognize the steady and significant improvement in the quality of care for skilled nursing care center residents instead of considering more regulation of an “already overburdened sector.” 

The statement by Mark Parkinson, president and chief executive officer of AHCA, came before a House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations hearing titled “Examining Federal Efforts to Ensure Quality of Care and Resident Safety in Nursing Homes.”

He said while the discussion agenda is focused on whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and Office of Inspector General exercise enough oversight to ensure residents are free from abuse and receive proper care, such a debate is missing the point and continues a pattern of disrespecting the nursing care profession.

“At a time when Congress faces public criticism for its failure to work together and accomplish shared goals, this hearing seems like a misguided effort to find more ways to regulate an already overburdened sector,” Parkinson said. Long term care is one of the most regulated industries in the country, “yet we’ve shown some of the most dramatic improvement on both self-reported and government quality measures.”

  …

Read it here 


Article 2:   

Quality Improvement Projects Save Children’s Hospitals Millions, Jacqueline LaPointe, RevCycle Intelligence, 6/21/2018

Clay’s summary: Better management of asthma in pediatric populations can pay off. So can avoiding medical errors.

Key Passage from the Article

With their drive to deliver high-value care in mind, Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Ohio and Yale New Haven Children’s Hospital in Connecticut embarked on quality improvements efforts to address specific issues within their organizations that were impacting patient outcomes and cost.

Their quality improvement projects paid off in more ways than one. Nationwide has reported significant improvements in asthma control, resulting in $5.2 million in savings, while Yale New Haven Children’s Hospital has seen patient safety and error reporting increase, catching $3 million in savings for the hospital.

  …

Read it here 

 

 


 

Article 3:   

CMS Awards $5.5M to Develop Palliative Care Quality Measures, Kaitlyn Mattson, Home Health Care News, 9/30/2018

Clay’s summary: Efforts to bring palliative care into value-based care are in the early stages.

Key Passage from the Article

The American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine (AAHPM), in partnership with the National Coalition for Hospice and Palliative Care and the RAND Corporation, has been awarded a three-year $5.5 million grant from Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to develop patient-reported quality measures for community-based palliative care.

Filling the gaps in quality measurement of palliative care is one of the main sticking points for the three-year grant, according to AAHPM.

One of the many reasons to develop measures is because major gaps were observed in quality measurement for people with serious illness, according to a 2015 report measuring quality indictors for hospice and palliative carefrom AAHPM and the Hospice and Palliative Nurses Association.

  …

Read it here 

 


 

Posted on

Monday Morning Medicaid Must Reads: October 15th, 2018

Helping you consider differing viewpoints. Before it’s illegal. 

 

Article 1:  

Insurers Are Using AI to Boost Risk Management, Jared Kaltwasser, Healthcare Analytics News, 10/2/2018

Clay’s summary: Pretty blatant press-release dressed up as “news,” but interesting read nonetheless.

Key Passage from the Article

“The growth of value-based care is driving the need for deeper healthcare insights, for key activities such as risk adjustment, quality reporting, care and utilization management,” Apixio CEO Darren Schulte, M.D., told Healthcare Analytics News™.

The company’s pitch looks something like this: The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is increasing audits of health plans offering Medicaid Advantage (MA), to ensure correct payments. That means health plans have to keep careful tabs on coding and payments. But unless the health plan owns the clinic, providers don’t share the same financial risks as insurers.

Apixio says about 85-95 percent of MA risk-adjustment payments are based on diagnosis codes from clinics and hospitals. The remaining payments are from chart coding. Diagnosis codes are backed up by patient notes and physician codes, but those records aren’t often reviewed prior to payment by the health plans. Thus, any errors may go undiscovered, which could cause regulatory headaches for health plans — but usually not clinics.

  …

Read it here 


Article 2:   

Enhanced Patient Matching Is Critical to Achieving Full Promise of Digital Health Records, Pew Trusts, 10/2/2018

Clay’s summary: Care management only works if you are treating the right patient.. kind of makes me think about how they write “not this one” on the leg that is not to be cut off going into surgery..

Key Passage from the Article

This report focuses on the last problem—patient matching—while also recognizing that many other challenges remain for effective and robust interoperability.

Patient matching helps address interoperability by determining whether records—both those held within a single facility and those in different health care organizations—correctly refer to a specific individual. Unfortunately, patient matching rates vary widely, with health care facilities failing to link records for the same patient as often as half the time. Deficiencies in matching patients to their records can lead to safety problems: For example, if an allergy listed in one record is not documented in another, or if records for two different individuals are incorrectly merged, patient harm can occur. In a 2012 survey conducted by the College of Healthcare Information Management Executives (CHIME), 1 in 5 hospital chief information officers indicated that patients had been harmed in the previous year due to mismatches.

Failures to effectively match patients can also be costly, leading to repeat tests and delays in care. In an extreme example, the care for an 11-month-old twin was documented in her sister’s record, resulting in the failure of the health system to recoup $43,000 in costs from the insurer.

  …

Read it here 

 


 

Article 3:   

Patient-Centered Medical Home Evidence Increases With Time, Paul Cotton, Health Affairs, 9/10/2018

Clay’s summary: Still losing money in year 7 of your health home? Don’t give up just yet- Health Affairs says they work, so they must work!

Key Passage from the Article

There are clear differences between studies that do and do not find benefits. Positive evaluations assess PCMHs on advanced standards, after up to five years of transformation and with financial incentives to improve quality and efficiency, or—like the HIV study above, the impact with high-cost, high-needs patients. Studies showing little benefit assessed practices with no financial incentives to reward improvement. They also looked at PCMHs using our initial 2008 standards that we updated in 2011, 2014, and 2017. The 2011 updates further emphasize pediatrics, health information technology, and clinician-patient collaboration. We made 2014 updates to emphasize more behavioral health care integration, team-based care, focus on high-need populations care management, and patient and family involvement. We made 2017 updates to streamline our recognition process and better support practices. And we will continue making updates in the future as we continuously listen to stakeholder feedback on how to improve this powerful program. 

PCMHs do, in fact, work. That is why the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA), which rewards clinicians for value instead of volume, gives PCMHs automatic credit. That is why 27 public-sector initiatives across 23 states and many private insurers use the NCQA PCMH model. That is why key medical boards provide PCMH credit for Maintenance of Certification. And that is why approximately 20 percent of all primary care physicians in the US are in the NCQA-recognized PCMH practices.

  …

Read it here